In the Way Too Much TV Era, it truly is an honor just to be nominated.
Imagine that you’re working on a television series, one of the many actors, writers and others who give
daily thanks for the rise of cable and streaming that has led to gazillions — at least — of shows and
growing employment opportunities. Then, besides the possibility of at least your mom spotting you in the
vast video sea, you learn that your peers watched and, hallelujah, decreed you Emmy worthy.
Who needs to win? Every nominee, of course, who would prefer to avoid being an also-ran smiling bravely
for the cameras. There’s also the producers of the Sept. 22 Emmy Awards ceremony and Fox , the network
airing it, with an event to sell.
"Game of Thrones," ”Veep" and "When They See Us" look like front-runners but
the outcome is anyone’s guess. AP Television Writer Lynn Elber and Entertainment Writer Mark Kennedy’s
offer theirs in the top categories.
DRAMA SERIES
ELBER:
Should win: "Pose." An opulent, clear-eyed embrace of the late-20th-century LGBTQ ballroom
scene deserves its due.
Will win: "Game of Thrones." A landmark show that brought cinematic sweep to TV gets a big
farewell, finale naysayers be damned.
KENNEDY:
Should win: Agreed on "Pose," a loving look at a world that has never been celebrated on TV
before, starring the largest LGBTQ cast ever for a scripted series.
Will win: "Pose" is up against the behemoth "Game of Thrones," which triggered
parodies and homages, memes and talk show publicity. Even the president tried to co-opt its tagline
"Winter Is Coming." The Emmy is coming.
COMEDY SERIES
ELBER:
Should win: "Fleabag." Such shocking sexual abandon and emotional dysfunction is downright
un-American. Three cheers for this British invasion!
Will win: "Veep." A three-for-three winner won’t be defeated in its last hurrah, especially
when politics are all the rage.
KENNEDY:
Should win: The second season of "Fleabag" — with a woman resisting her feelings for a priest —
and the debut of "Russian Doll" — in which a New Yorker keeps reliving the night of her 36th
birthday — were deeply worthy of wins for writing and originality.
Will win: "Veep," the safe and more popular choice. But Emmy voters may learn to regret this
predictable decision.
ACTOR, DRAMA SERIES
ELBER:
Should win: Billy Porter, "Pose." The Tony-winning actor’s performance, by turns brassy, tender
and brave, anchors the sprawling drama.
Will win: Billy Porter. He found the TV role he deserved and gets the award he earned.
KENNEDY:
Should win: Yes, yes, yes. Porter is always the best thing in whatever he’s in and he’s truly fierce in
"Pose." But did enough people watch?
Will win: Kit Harington, buffeted by the waves of "Game of Thrones" nostalgia, will give a
knightly farewell to Jon Snow with a statuette.
ACTRESS, DRAMA SERIES
ELBER:
Should win: Sandra Oh, "Killing Eve." A tour-de-force performance of vulnerability and, to her
character’s dismay, brutality.
Will win: Sandra Oh. Deserved, history-making recognition as she becomes the first actress of Asian
descent to win a lead actress trophy. Also makes up for her five "Grey’s Anatomy" supporting
nods without wins.
KENNEDY:
Should win: The mouse to Sandra Oh’s cat — Jodie Comer. She has, criminally, not earned enough
recognition for her special brand of killer.
Will win: Sandra Oh. Especially since there’s no Claire Foy from "The Crown" to ruin her night.
ACTOR, COMEDY SERIES
ELBER:
Should win: Bill Hader, "Barry." His scarily winning portrayal of a hit man with a Hollywood
dream was voted tops last year and remains deserving.
Will win: Michael Douglas, "The Kominsky Method." The movie star’s inner comedian comes out and
plays, wowing Emmy voters.
KENNEDY:
Should win: Hader already has his Emmy. Douglas won a Golden Globe for "The Kominsky Method."
The Emmy should go to Anthony Anderson, the beating heart of "black-ish," who makes lovingly
exasperated completely hysterical but has been overlooked too long.
Will win: The award clearly will go to Eugene Levy, who is a comedic treasure and rightfully should be
showered with awards. His last Emmy was in 1983. It’s time, people.
ACTRESS, COMEDY SERIES
ELBER:
Should win: Catherine O’Hara, "Schitt’s Creek." Consider it a lifetime achievement award, with
her delectably self-absorbed, absurd Moira topping her inventive catalog of characters (and yes, I’m
including the Christopher Guest films. Movies, TV — it’s all the same now).
Will win: Julia Louis-Dreyfus, "Veep." The queen of TV comedy ("Seinfeld," ”The New
Adventures of Old Christine," this) will add a record-setting ninth Emmy to her haul, breaking a
tie with Cloris Leachman for most-honored performer ever.
KENNEDY:
Should win: Phoebe Waller-Bridge, who in "Fleabag" needs only to look over her shoulder at us,
lower her eyes and convey everything that’s churning in her complex mind.
Will win: Julia Louis-Dreyfus. Who is silly enough to vote against her?
LIMITED SERIES
ELBER:
Should win: "When They See Us." The superb cast, the unsparing writing, the dismaying currency
of a 20-year-old case’s implications for American justice and racial inequality demand an Emmy.
Will win: "When They See Us." "Chernobyl" is a deeply worthy competitor, but Emmy
voters put domestic concerns first.
KENNEDY:
Should win: In many ways, this category represented the best of TV this season — "Chernobyl,"
”Escape at Dannemora," ”Fosse/Verdon," ”When They See Us" and "Sharp
Objects." Any is a worthy winner.
Will win: "When They See Us," perhaps the best of this exciting category. It had searing
acting, harrowing circumstances and brilliant writing.
___
Online:
http://www.emmys.com
___
Lynn Elber is at [email protected] and on Twitter at http://twitter.com/lynnelber . Mark Kennedy is at
http://twitter.com/KennedyTwits .
