CHARLESTON, S.C. — Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church opened its tall, wooden doors to the world
Sunday, embracing strangers who walked in from the street or tuned in from home for the first worship
service since a white gunman was accused of killing nine black church members.
It was that same hospitality that allowed the suspected gunman to be welcomed into a Bible study for
about an hour before he allegedly stood up, made racially offensive remarks and opened fire in the
church known as "Mother Emanuel" because it is one of the oldest black congregations in the
"I was so pleased when authorities told us you can go back into ‘Mother Emanuel’ to worship,"
said the Rev. Norvel Goff, a presiding elder of the 7th District AME Church in South Carolina, before
adding a note of defiance to a service sprinkled with themes of love, recovery and healing.
"Some folks might need some more time in order to walk in. But for those of us who are here this
morning … because the doors of Mother Emanuel are open on this Sunday, it sends a message to every
demon in hell and on earth."
The church’s air conditioning did little to fight the heat of extra bodies in the sanctuary. There was
fervent singing and shouting, so much so that many congregants waved small fans in front of their faces.
Despite the heaviness in the air, many stood — some holding small children — to shout their praises or
raise their hands toward the church’s vaulted ceiling. For added security, police officers stood watch
Some congregation members stood to applaud when Goff thanked law enforcement for their response to the
Goff was appointed to lead the historic Charleston church after Emanuel’s senior pastor, the Rev.
Clementa Pinckney, was fatally shot during the massacre. A black sheet was draped over Pinckney’s usual
chair, which sat empty. At least one parishioner kneeled down in front of it and prayed.
Pinckney was also a state senator and married father of two children. Goff acknowledged Father’s Day and
said: "The only way evil can triumph is for good folks to sit down and do nothing."
As Emanuel’s congregation belted out a gospel hymn, church bells rang throughout the "Holy
City" —nicknamed because of the numerous churches here. Later Sunday, thousands of people gathered
on the Arthur Ravenel Bridge to join hands in solidarity.
The bridge is named after a former state lawmaker and vocal Confederate flag supporter. The slayings have
renewed calls for the flag to be removed from the South Carolina Statehouse grounds, in part because
photographs of Roof in a purported manifesto showed him holding Confederate flags. The 2,500-word
manifesto also contained hate-filled writings.
Less than 2 miles from the church, someone vandalized a Confederate monument, spray-painting "Black
Lives Matter" on the statue. City workers used a tarp to cover up the graffiti, police said.
Photos on local news websites from before the tarp was put up showed the graffiti in bright red paint,
along with the message "This is the problem. # RACIST."
Around the country, pastors asked people to pray for Charleston. In Atlanta’s 1st Iconium Baptist Church,
a predominantly black church with a tradition of speaking out for social justice, the Rev. Timothy
McDonald told his congregation Sunday that he had met Pinckney last April during a visit to Columbia,
South Carolina, with a group of ministers.
"You talk about a promising young man," he said, expressing shock at the manner of Pinckney’s
"How do you sit in a Bible Study next to a pastor for almost an hour and then you just stand up and
shoot to kill? That kind of hate, that kind of evil – we need God y’all. We need Jesus," McDonald
The tragedy resonated far beyond urban areas. Congregants at a small church in rural north-central
Pennsylvania signed a condolence card to send to Emanuel. The Rev. Nancy Light Hardy of St. James United
Church of Christ said she debated mailing the card, which seemed "pitiful and lame" when set
against the "inconceivable" killings.
"But at least it lets the Charleston church know that Christians across the country are thinking
about them," she said.
The welcoming spirit Roof exploited before the shooting was still alive.
Gail Lincoln said she typically attends another AME church nearby, but felt compelled to visit Emanuel
"Through all of this, God is still our refuge," Lincoln said. "I’m still heartbroken, but
it’s going to get better. I know it’s going to take time, day by day."
As a further sign of resilience, the church’s Wednesday night Bible study is expected to continue as
normal next week, said Emanuel member Harold Washington, 75.
"We didn’t change a thing," he said.
Associated Press contributors include Mike Stewart, Don Schanche, David Goldman, Emily Masters, Allen
Breed, Josh Replogle and John Mone.
Copyright 2015 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast,
rewritten or redistributed.