David Gilbert went to prison a revolutionary, raising his fist and scorning authorities who prosecuted
him for an infamous 1981 armored truck robbery in which a guard and two police officers were killed.
Four decades later, advocates for the 76-year-old inmate’s release include San Francisco’s chief
prosecutor, the son left behind at 14 months old when both his parents were arrested.
"As long as I can remember, I’ve known that the most likely scenario is that my father is going to
die in prison," said Chesa Boudin, sworn in as district attorney last year.
Boudin ran a progressive campaign in which he said visiting his parents Kathy Boudin and Gilbert in
prison showed him the criminal justice system was broken.
Gilbert is among the last surviving people still imprisoned in the bungled 1981 Brink’s robbery north of
New York City, often seen as a last gasp of ’60s radicalism. The robbery still stirs emotions,
especially among local officials and relatives of the slain men who have watched with exasperation as
others convicted in the crime, including Kathy Boudin, walk out of prison.
As one of many voices lobbying New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, Chesa Boudin’s support for his father’s
clemency is personal. But the case also revolves around questions of justice the Democrat and former
public defender deals with as a district attorney.
"No matter whether my father lives the rest of his life in a cage or whether he’s released to spend
his few remaining years with family, we can’t undo the harm that his crime cost. And we can’t bring back
the men who were so wrongfully killed that day." he said in a recent interview. "At what point
is enough enough? I don’t know."
Gilbert is serving a 75-year-to-life sentence at the Shawangunk Correctional Facility for the Oct. 20,
1981 robbery of $1.6 million from a Brink’s truck at a suburban Rockland County mall. He is eligible for
parole in 2056.
Veterans of the Weather Underground, a militant group that grew out of the anti-Vietnam War movement,
joined with members of the Black Liberation Army in a robbery they considered a justified
"expropriation" to establish a Black nation in the South called the Republic of New Afrika.
Brink’s guard Peter Paige and two Nyack policemen, Sgt. Edward O’Grady and Officer Waverly Brown, were
killed in the holdup and ensuing shootout at a nearby roadblock.
Gilbert, an unarmed getaway driver, was charged with robbery and murder since people were killed during
the crime. He and two co-defendants cast themselves as freedom fighters and deemed their trial
illegitimate. At one court session, Gilbert and co-defendant Judith Clark raised their fists and shouted
"Free the land!"
Steve Zeidman, the lawyer and CUNY School of Law professor spearheading the clemency campaign, said
Gilbert has a spotless prison record and has helped fellow inmates since running an AIDS education
program during that epidemic. Supporters of his release range from fellow inmates to former South
African archbishop Desmond Tutu.
As COVID-19 spreads through New York’s prisons, Zeidman stressed that Gilbert is especially vulnerable as
one of the system’s oldest and longest-serving inmates. Gilbert is eligible for the vaccine, though his
son said he had yet to receive a shot.
Chesa Boudin was dropped off at a babysitter before the robbery and was later raised by his parents’
Weather Underground compatriots, Bill Ayers and Bernardine Dohrn. Growing up, his relationship with his
biological parents was defined by phone calls and prison visits.
Boudin recalls Gilbert telling elaborate adventure stories on the phone starring the boy and his friends
sailing down the Amazon River or in some other exotic locale. Each call would be an episode. Pictures
taken at prison visits over the decades show a young boy with tousled hair grow into the bearded lawyer
eventually elected DA.
Kathy Boudin avoided a harsher sentence by pleading guilty and was paroled in 2003. Clark was granted
parole in 2019, three years after Cuomo commuted her sentence, noting her "exceptional strides in
Each release raises vocal opposition
John Hanchar, O’Grady’s nephew, asked why Gilbert’s case was worthy of public attention when so many
inmates with lesser convictions get none. Hanchar contends Gilbert helped plan a crime that left a
lasting hole in the lives of the slain men’s families.
"We’ve moved on with our lives. But fair is fair. If you want to say that this guy spent 40 years in
prison and he’s going to leave an old man, I don’t care if he leaves tomorrow," Hanchar said.
"But don’t tell me that he didn’t kill these people."
There’s a separate effort to secure the release of former Black Liberation Army leader Mutulu Shakur, the
70-year-old stepfather of slain rapper Tupac Shakur. He is at a federal medical center in Kentucky and
has advanced-stage bone marrow cancer. Shakur was convicted of leading a group responsible for a series
of armed robberies in New York and Connecticut, including the Brink’s heist.
Zeidman, who also handled Clark’s case, said Gilbert’s case "kicked into high gear" with a
clemency filing last year and they have since added supplemental material. Advocates hope Cuomo
intervenes as he did with Clark, though clemencies for more serious crimes are rare among the state’s
33,000 inmates. The Democrat announced 14 pardons and seven commutations last Christmas Eve, a
traditional time for announcements.
Zeidman said he has not received a formal decision from Cuomo’s administration.
Gilbert declined a request to answer questions about his role in the crime and arguments for his release
that The Associated Press posed in a letter to him. Zeidman and Boudin describe Gilbert as remorseful
and no threat to society.
"This is just a question about how do we balance retribution against other social interests,"